Mention fruitcake, and most people think of a holiday paperweight. But Thomas McNutt, fourth-generation owner of Texas's historic Collin Street Bakery, says their 130-year-old recipe changes minds instantly.
Comparing it to putting on glasses for the very first time, McNutt says people tell them all day long that "I won't eat fruitcake — except yours."
"Most fruitcakes earn their reputation and are not the kind you want to eat, but ours is different. We just hear all day long all the time, 'I won't eat fruitcake except for Collin Street Bakery,'" McNutt says. "For that reason, we give an unconditional guarantee on our website, that this is the best fruitcake you've ever had or all of your money back."
Operating since the 1890s, the bakery combines native Texas pecans with pineapples from their very own Costa Rican farm. But fruitcake isn't all they do. They're a full-scratch bakery with a menu larger than an ice cream parlor's — and a pedigree that once caught the attention of the White House.
"My dad read in the Wall Street Journal years ago that White House pastry chef, Roland Mesnier, who the White House pastry chef for five U.S. presidents... Wrote him a letter and said, 'Hey, thank you so much for your service... Roland, if you get bored, please come work with us.' And he got bored, and he came and worked with us," McNutt states
Today, those presidential and century-old recipes ship from a small Corsicana kitchen to all 50 states and over 100 countries.
Whether ordering online or picking up a White House pumpkin cake this season, it's a taste of multigenerational craftsmanship.
"If we hit our plan this year, we're going to bake 1.1 million pounds of this famous Christmas fruitcake and ship to all 50 states and 100 countries — about a little over a million pounds of cake this year, Lord willing," McNutt says.
To taste the tradition for yourself, visit CollinStreet.com.