President Trump enjoyed unprecedented Hispanic support in 2024, famously winning Hispanic-majority Starr County on the Texas-Mexico border two years ago. In the Nov. 3 election, Starr County swung 58 points to Democrats on the ballot.
Much like exit polls showed young white men swinging toward Democrats, young Latino voters went from a plus-2 support for Trump in 2024 to plus-37 for Democrats two weeks ago.
Rev. Sammy Rodriguez, who leads the National Hispanic Christian Leadership Conference, told American Family News one looming issue cost Republicans the Hispanic vote in the midterms: illegal immigration.
“The optics of immigration, and more than any angst regarding the deportation of cartels and pedophiles and rapists and murderers,” Rodriguez shares, “was picking up the 65-year-old abuela who makes tortillas.”
Many – or most – Republican voters recognize the difference between a hard-working roofer and a convicted rapist, but want them both deported because they are on U.S. soil illegally and broke the law.
Knowing that is the view of many GOP voters, Rodriguez told AFN he was relieved to see President Trump back away from that deport-them-both stance in his post-election “60 Minutes” interview.
AFN previously reported President Trump told CBS News he was “too tough” on illegal immigration, and he wants to “work a deal” for illegal immigrants who are currently working a job in the U.S.
“The ‘60 Minutes’ interview was an answered prayer. Wow,” Rodriguez told AFN.
That post-election reversal, which surprised many, came after Trump promised the "largest deportation program" in history during the 2024 campaign.
What does amnesty mean?
After the CBS News interview, one controversial word being floated by critics of Trump’s softened stance is “amnesty” for illegal immigrants.
According to Rodriguez, “amnesty” means legally recognizing millions of illegal aliens as a U.S. citizen rather than the current discussion for granting those illegals a permit to remain here and work.
The idea of granting citizenship is often tied to Democrats when they talk about “immigration reform,” because it would grant their party millions of new voters thanks to the Democratic Party.
Rodriguez told AFN he has discussed that issue, and that particular word, with President Trump. The president opposes granting citizenship, and he was not talking about amnesty in the “60 Minutes” interview, Rodriguez insisted.
AFN reached out to the White House, asking for the Trump administration’s definition of “amnesty,” but was directed to President Trump’s “60 Minutes” interview in which he vowed no amnesty.
How many illegal immigrants living in U.S.?
President Trump's soft view on hard-working illegal immigrants is not new. He has told reporters in the past that farmers depend on them for labor and has mentioned an executive order that targets farm labor.
The number of illegal immigrants currently living in the United States is impossible to know. Pew Research estimates that number is 14 million. That number tracks closely with 13.5 million estimated by the Center for Immigration Studies.
FAIR, the Federation for Immigration Reform, estimates that number is 18.6 million, citing a surge of 4 million who were welcomed and allowed to remain during the Biden administration.
The arrest and deportation of illegal aliens is handled by Immigration and Customs Enforcement, or ICE, which is overseen by the Department of Homeland Security.
Figures released by ICE last week report it has arrested approximately 604,000 illegal immigrants, and Customs and Border Protection had arrested another 447,000, The Washington Examiner reported.
Those figures clash with previous numbers released by ICE during the current year, the Examiner reported, and an unnamed ICE official told reporter Anna Giaritelli those figures are doubtful because some are being double-counted.