/
AFN Android App
DOWNLOAD THE AFN Android App
Get
AFN iOS App
DOWNLOAD THE AFN iOS App
Get
Sutton: Disbanding NYC Strategic Response Group is a disaster waiting to happen

Sutton: Disbanding NYC Strategic Response Group is a disaster waiting to happen


Sutton: Disbanding NYC Strategic Response Group is a disaster waiting to happen

New York City's mayor is making good on a campaign promise that a law enforcement expert says will make the city much more dangerous.

During his campaign, Zohran Mamdani promised to essentially defang the New York Police Department (NYPD) by eliminating the city's riot police.

"As Mayor I will disband the SRG (Strategic Response Group) which has cost taxpayers millions in lawsuit settlements plus has brutalized countless New Yorkers exercising their First Amendment rights," he wrote on social media in December 2024.

On Monday, Mamdani announced that the NYPD's specialized rapid-deployment unit, created in 2015 to handle counterterrorism, major incidents and crowd control at protests, will be disbanded in the spring and the city will establish new resources to address public demonstrations.

"We are creating a Community Dialogue and De-escalation Division (CDDD) within the Mayor's Office of Community Safety to prepare for and respond to protests through dialogue and engagement," Mamdani said.

The SRG's responsibilities will be divided among three new teams and an existing bureau, separating protest response from counterterrorism operations.

Its counterterrorism duties will transfer to the existing Intelligence and Counterterrorism Bureau, while demonstration responses will be handled by three new teams focused on communication and vetted patrol support: the civilian-led CDDD, the NYPD's First Amendment Support Team (FAST) and the Patrol Support Division (PSD).

As reported by CBS New York, the overhaul also prohibits protest tactics such as tear gas, general pepper spray and kettling — a crowd-control tactic that contains protesters by surrounding them with officers or police barriers, effectively trapping them in a confined area. The changes beginning to take effect in January 2027.

"This will not be a uniformed police unit. It will be made up of civilians without weapons or arrest powers," the mayor said of the CDDD.

The elite SRG, which has approximately 500 officers, has been deployed during major emergencies, parades, protests and the papal visit. It also responded to the July 2025 Manhattan mass shooting that killed four people, including an NYPD officer.

Sutton, Lt. Randy Sutton

Beginning early next year, unarmed civilians will be responding to those types of situations and others, such as the violent protest that broke out in the city in October following the shooting of Oscar Belgal by plainclothes Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents.

Protesters gathered outside New York-Presbyterian Allen Hospital and rallied at Foley Square, demanding Belgal's release and an end to local ICE operations. Subsequent demonstrations escalated, including an Oct. 28 protest in which demonstrators blocked traffic on the Brooklyn Bridge, resulting in approximately 14 arrests.

The NYPD's aggressive crowd-control response during these demonstrations became a key catalyst for the city's decision to disband the SRG.

Although the CDDD will not operate on the front lines if a protest turns violent, Randy Sutton, a law enforcement advocate and author, says it is only a matter of time before a community safety officer is killed. 

"Anybody that chooses to respond to a protest, which we know often turns into a riot, and they don't have any of the tools necessary to defend themselves or others, are absolutely useless," he insists.

"I knew things were going to start getting bad under Mamdani, but this is not just bad, it is irrational," Sutton adds.