James Talarico, Adam Hamilton and Sarah Trone Garriott campaigned in their states on a socialist Jesus who wants America to throw open her borders to welcome the stranger and love her neighbor with tax dollars.
National Religious Broadcasters (NRB) President Troy Miller says this "socialist manifesto" is not what Jesus taught.
"Jesus really taught individual responsibility," he notes. "This was not a duty of the state; it was a duty of each person individually and each family."
In the Bible, a person's citizenship matters both legally and spiritually: the Apostle Paul uses his Roman citizenship to demand fair legal treatment and avoid flogging (Acts 22:25–29), while also reminding believers that their primary citizenship is in heaven (Philippians 3:20).
Regarding government, Jesus teaches that earthly authorities have a legitimate sphere of civic duty – telling followers to "render to Caesar the things that are Caesar's, and to God the things that are God's" (Matthew 22:21) – while clarifying to Pontius Pilate that earthly rulers only possess power granted from above and that His own kingdom is not of this world (John 18:36, 19:11).
According to the Bible, Miller says the primary purpose of the government "is to uphold righteous laws and to protect people and to punish the wicked."
Nevertheless, Talarico, Hamilton and Garriott are now poised to push for Christian socialist policies in the U.S.
Miller, whose work with the Bible centers on media advocacy, apologetics and practical faith application, says Talarico is even trying to sell his colleagues on the second coming of Lyndon Johnson's "Great Society" plan. That was a sweeping domestic reform agenda the Democratic-led Congress passed in the 1960s to end poverty, reduce racial injustice, and expand federal social programs.
"James Talarico made a real plea for the parties to work together to get these kinds of things passed," Miller says.
The irony of Talarico and others embracing their version of Christianity is Democrats continually warn their base that "Christian nationalists" pose a fascist-like threat to democracy.
Miller believes these Democrats headed to Congress lack the common sense to known socialism is destined to fail and bring the country down with it.
The other side has a common answer for that accusation, too: "Real communism has never been tried."
"They have this idea that it just hasn't worked before because we just haven't tried it correctly; this time, we're going to get it right," Miller says.
Speaking as someone who is concerned about declining biblical literacy, he asks pastors to keep teaching their congregations correct theology that they can bring to the polls in 2028.
"I hope there are enough Christians out there who understand and reject this idea that 'love your neighbor' means you pay for everything that they don't have," the NRB president states.