Transgender athlete ban, backed by Noem, clears committee

Transgender athlete ban, backed by Noem, clears committee

Transgender athlete ban, backed by Noem, clears committee

PIERRE, S.D. — A South Dakota legislative committee on Friday approved a bill championed by Gov. Kristi Noem to ban males who claim to be females from participating in women's school sports leagues.

With the Republican governor's full-fledged lobbying, the bill received enthusiastic approval in the Republican-dominated Senate State Affairs committee, clearing a legislative hurdle that has been a key roadblock to similar South Dakota bills in the past. It was the first bill the committee took up this year as lawmakers try to fast-track it through the Statehouse.

Every Republican on the committee approved the bill, despite warnings from opponents that it exposes public schools to legal action for a political cause that has not been an issue in South Dakota. Proponents say it protects girls’ sports from trans athletes who may be bigger, faster and stronger than their peers.

If the bill passes the Legislature, South Dakota could be the 10th Republican-dominated state to adopt such a ban on males who claim to be females and want to compete in women's sports. In two of those states — Idaho and West Virginia — the laws have been halted by federal judges. President Joe Biden's Justice Department has attacked bans in other states, claiming they are violations of federal law.

But lawmakers have used as ammunition the Pennsylvania case of a 22-year-old male who claims to be a female who has been defeating females in swimming competitions for the University of Pennsylvania, as proof that trans athletes possess an unfair advantage over their competition.

“Allowing males to compete destroys fair competition and athletic opportunities for girls," Rachel Oglesby, the governor's policy advisor, told the committee. "Similarly gifted and trained males will always have physical advantages over females.”

Groups representing public schools said politicians are forcing them to choose between violating state law or federal policy. The Associated School Boards warned that schools could lose federal funds if an investigation from the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services found them to have violated students' rights.

In an acknowledgment that schools were being put at legal risk, the governor's office amended the bill to stipulate that the state would provide legal representation and pay the costs of any lawsuits. Mark Miller, the governor's chief of staff, insisted that the proposed law complied with the Constitution, that other states had successfully implemented similar laws and the state would prevail in court if sued.

Noem last year shied away from signing a similar bill, issuing a “style and form veto” and arguing that it was flawed because it put the state at risk of litigation and retribution from the NCAA.

But this year, she seized on the momentum of a cause taking hold among Republicans and trumpeted her support for “protecting fairness in women's sports."

Noem launched a campaign ad this week that claimed she “never backed down” on the issue. And if there was any doubt that her political ambitions lie beyond South Dakota — the state where she is running for reelection and where the proposed law would take effect — the ad is running on channels nationwide.

Jon Schweppe, the director of policy at the social conservative group, American Principles Project, praised Noem's bill after last year slamming her for effectively killing the legislation.

“To see her now coming out with a stronger bill, to see her championing this issue and making it her priority, we haven’t really seen anything like that before with Republicans," he said. "I think it’s a significant moment."